When we first started reading The Gold Mountain Coat story in the class…. I thought the focus of the story would be in the narrator, the little girl. So as we read line after line I was anticipating that the course of events would shift any time to bring the little girl in. Nevertheless, the little girl wasn’t the main character and the story was all about Sam Sing and his sons. It is an interesting twist thought; perhaps the writer wanted it to be this way as a sort of a hook. And the story I think is the best description of the Chinese way of living at that particular era. So the story through its proceedings described the hard working, thrifts, and family unity in spite of the personal differences. In fact, it is an ideal reflection of the Chinese culture, which is unlike the Canadian. It is hardly to find grown men in Canadian culture who will be blindly obeying their parents never the less being so submissive and out of character. We can see this clearly when John went to visit the little girl’s mother and he was so upset and scared that his father might not allow him to buy a new coat. Although he was aware of his rights and he mentioned in that visit “this isn’t China”, later on when he was actually in front of his father he could not get rid of his obedient nature. Therefore, the description of Chinese families was authentic and most probably this credited to the writer’s background.
I am so surprised with your huge vocabulary!
ReplyDeletePersonally, I'm not interested in the story, but it is very interesting at some points as you mentioned.
We could see those kinds of men who obey their patrents in Korean long long time ago. Still there are many people who consider what their parents think very much when they make a decision in my country. Somtimes..so do I.
How about your country?
After I read this blog, I came to like "The Gold Mountain Coat" more!
ReplyDeleteYou are graet reader!
Hee-Jung I am pleased with your comment. As for your question regarding my country... well it depends a lot in each family' values. It is true in my country we almost share the same culture and values.. but like any where else you can find some families more liberate and others more traditional.. And so are the men...some of them place great importance in their families' approval but it never gets closer to what was descried in the story... For example men can show respect and grant their families approval in their personal decision like education & marriage but have the freedom in other aspects..
ReplyDeleteChieu,, Thanks...
ReplyDeleteThank you for giving me the details!
ReplyDeleteMy parents kind of want me to get married, but I keep denying now. haha. In Korea, marriage is a big deal for girls who are over 26 years old. However, they understand not only what I want to do, but also what I don't want to. Since I came here, I really want to stay here and study more. I hope we can see each other in Ph.D program at UBC.
p.s. Francis wants me to say hello to you. He is in China now. I hope we can have dinner with him when he comes back!
Hee-Jung, your comment reminded me of a funny news story I read just a few days ago on the subject of a woman who was tired of family pressures to get married. The link above is actually not to the news story, but to the actual artist's website.
ReplyDeleteSabha, I identified very much with what you wrote regarding your expectation that the narrator would be more involved in the plot; I has the same expectation when I first read the story. She is an excellent narrator, but I also think that her story is more subtle than that of the men and their bargaining over their coat.
ReplyDeleteIncidentally, one of the reasons why I like this story is because it shows the clash of values across not only a cultural gap, but a generational one. As far as Chinese families go nowadays, though, I think the vast majority of them would not be able to identify with the experience of Sam Sing.